A To Z Mysteries Super Edition 7

A Super Secret (and Slightly Silly) Confession

Okay, let's talk A to Z Mysteries Super Edition #7: The New Year's Eve Sleepover. I have something to admit. And it might be controversial.

Ready for it? I think it's...overrated. Don't get me wrong; I love Dink, Josh, and Ruth Rose. But this one? Eh, it's not my favorite.

The Case of the Missing Sparkle (and Maybe Some Fun)

The premise is cute: a New Year's Eve sleepover. But the mystery felt a bit...underwhelming. A missing celebrity's dog, Princess, leads to a city-wide hunt in New York City.

The kids get separated, and it feels more like chaotic exploration than a cohesive mystery. It's like they're wandering, not investigating. I like a tighter plot, thank you very much.

And frankly, New York City? Felt underutilized. The setting wasn't as vibrant as it could have been. Maybe I just wanted more iconic landmarks.

Unpopular Opinion Alert!

I know, I know. People love this book. But hear me out! Other Super Editions feel more…super. They have bigger stakes and more interesting puzzles.

Remember The Bald Bandit? A missing museum exhibit and a daring art heist! Now that’s what I call thrilling. Or how about The Runaway Racehorse? A real horse race and high stakes!

Even The Falcon's Feathers feels more exotic and compelling. I can't help but compare The New Year's Eve Sleepover against these greats. Sadly, it often falls short.

Is it All Bad? Of Course Not!

Okay, I’m not a complete grump. The friendship between the kids shines through. Dink's bravery, Josh's enthusiasm, and Ruth Rose's rhyming skills—they're all there.

And the New Year's Eve setting is cozy. The idea of ringing in the new year with friends is always appealing. But overall the case feels less memorable to me.

I also enjoyed the introduction of a new character. Learning about new people adds layers to Green Lawn and the children's lives. However, is it enough to salvage the mystery?

Let's Talk Red Herrings

Let’s be honest: Red herrings are a staple of any good mystery. And this book has them. But sometimes they felt a little forced.

Did they really add to the suspense? Or just muddy the waters? It is important to have suspicion surround many people, I suppose.

Maybe I’m being too harsh. Perhaps I wanted more clues, more intrigue, and more…sparkle. After all, it's New Year's Eve!

The Verdict (and a Challenge)

So, there you have it: My slightly unpopular opinion. A to Z Mysteries Super Edition #7: The New Year's Eve Sleepover? A decent read, but not top-tier.

Still a fun read for young kids? Yes! But among the super edition book selection. Is it the best? Probably not.

But hey, maybe I’m wrong. Maybe you love this book. Tell me why! I’m open to changing my mind. Let’s discuss in the comments below! What did you enjoy most about the sleepover investigation?

Perhaps, in the end, any A to Z Mysteries adventure is worth reading. But this one sits lower on my list. I'm just being honest.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I'm going to go reread The Bald Bandit. Now *that* is a super edition!