So, you're thinking about diving into the world of alchemy, huh? Specifically, Fullmetal Alchemist.
Good choice! But then you stumble upon a question that splits fandoms: Do I NEED to watch the original FMA (2003) before FMA: Brotherhood?
The Great Debate: 2003 vs. Brotherhood
Everyone has an opinion. Some say it's anime blasphemy to skip the OG FMA. Others scream that Brotherhood is the only true path.
Well, I'm here to stir the pot. I have a confession to make. It might be unpopular.
My (Slightly Heretical) Opinion
Here it comes: You probably don't NEED to watch the 2003 version first. GASP!
Okay, okay, hear me out. Let's break this down.
Brotherhood follows the manga more closely. Meaning, it sticks to the original story that the author, Hiromu Arakawa, intended.
The 2003 anime diverged. It took a different path after a certain point. It created its own ending. A totally valid, yet different ending.
Why Brotherhood Can Stand Alone
Brotherhood does a pretty good job of introducing the characters. Also, it covers the initial plot points. You won't be totally lost.
It has a quicker pace. Perfect for binge-watching in our instant-gratification world.
Think of it like this: Brotherhood is like reading the definitive director's cut of a movie. You get the full, intended vision.
And the animation? Let's just say it's a bit more polished in Brotherhood.
But Wait, There's More! (The Case for 2003)
Don't get me wrong! FMA (2003) isn't bad. Not at all!
It has a darker, grittier tone. Some argue the character development is deeper, especially for some of the supporting cast.
The music is phenomenal. Seriously, the soundtrack is top-tier anime history.
It explores themes in a different way. It's a unique experience in its own right.
So, What Should You Do?
Here's the deal. If you have tons of time and a burning passion for anime, watch BOTH!
Start with FMA (2003), then move onto Brotherhood. Appreciate the differences. Compare and contrast!
If you're short on time, or just want the "canon" story? Dive straight into Brotherhood.
You can always go back and watch the 2003 version later. Think of it as a fascinating alternate universe.
The Final Verdict (My Biased Opinion)
I personally watched Brotherhood first. I survived. I thrived!
I didn't feel lost or confused. I fell in love with Edward and Alphonse.
Then, I went back and watched the 2003 version. It was a different experience. It was enjoyable!
Ultimately, it's your journey. Choose your own alchemic adventure!
Just remember, the most important thing is to enjoy the world of Fullmetal Alchemist. No matter which path you choose.
Now, go forth and transmute some awesome anime experiences!
"A lesson without pain is meaningless. That’s because no one can gain something without sacrificing something else in return." - Edward Elric (in both versions!)
