I Want It That Way Brooklyn 99 Episode

Okay, let's talk about "I Want It That Way." You know, the Brooklyn Nine-Nine episode. The one everyone *loves*.

The Usual Suspects (and Sung Harmony)

It's iconic. Jake Peralta gets a lineup to sing "I Want It That Way." Cue instant internet fame. But here's my controversial take: is it *overrated*?

Don't get me wrong, it's funny. The deadpan expressions are gold. Seeing the suspects awkwardly harmonize? Comedy genius.

But is it the *best* episode ever? That's where I raise an eyebrow.

The Hype is Real (But...)

The whole "I Want It That Way" bit is undeniably catchy. It sticks in your head for days. It's a perfect example of Brooklyn Nine-Nine's quirky humor.

And yes, it's brilliantly executed. The actors sell the scene perfectly. It's a meme factory, basically.

But does the *entire* episode hold up beyond that one scene? I'm not so sure.

Beyond the Song: What Else is There?

The actual plot isn't super memorable, is it? Something about a jewelry store robbery, if I remember correctly. It fades into the background.

Let's be real, you could probably skip the rest of the episode. And still feel like you got the "I Want It That Way" experience. The song is the main draw.

Other Brooklyn Nine-Nine episodes have more depth. They explore character development. They have stronger storylines.

Unpopular Opinion Alert!

Maybe I'm just a grumpy Gus. Maybe I'm tired of seeing the "I Want It That Way" clip everywhere. Maybe I just like other episodes better.

Like, the Halloween Heist episodes are always a riot. And the ones where Holt shows a rare crack of a smile? Those are priceless.

Those episodes have rewatchability factor. And not just for a 15-second clip of a Backstreet Boys song.

Still Funny, Just Maybe Not That Funny

Look, I'm not saying "I Want It That Way" is bad. It's hilarious. It's quotable. It's a cultural phenomenon.

But in the grand scheme of Brooklyn Nine-Nine? It's good, not great. It gets so much love because of the song.

So next time you're watching, appreciate the whole package. Don't let the musical number overshadow the rest. There are other gems in Brooklyn Nine-Nine's crown. They deserve attention too.