Should I Watch Fullmetal Alchemist Before Brotherhood
So, you're thinking about diving into the world of alchemy, automail, and emotionally scarred brothers, huh? Excellent choice! But then you hit the big question: Fullmetal Alchemist or Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood... which first?!
Don't worry, my friend, it's a common dilemma, like choosing between pizza and tacos (a delicious but stressful decision!). I'm here to help you navigate this alchemic conundrum!
The Case for Starting with the Original (2003)
Think of the original Fullmetal Alchemist (2003) as the theatrical trailer. It introduces you to the world, the characters, and the basic plot points at a slightly slower pace.
It’s like dipping your toes in the pool before cannonballing into the deep end. You get to savor the initial mysteries and the emotional weight of Edward and Alphonse Elric's journey.
The first few episodes of both series are pretty similar. But the 2003 version really lingers on those early moments, letting the atmosphere and the tragedy sink in.
Plus, the original anime deviates from the manga pretty early on. So, you get a unique and compelling story that explores some darker themes. It's like getting two totally different flavors of the same fantastic ice cream!
Imagine reading a mystery novel where the detective doesn't quite follow the book. It’s still a compelling narrative, just…different!
Why Some Folks Say "Skip It!"
Now, some people will yell at you and say "NO! Brotherhood is the only true path!" These people are probably also yelling at clouds, so take their advice with a grain of salt.
The main argument against the original is that it eventually veers away from the original manga's plot. And some fans are purists.
They want that pure, unadulterated Fullmetal Alchemist experience! But who wants only one experience?
Brotherhood: The Manga-Accurate Masterpiece
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (2009) is considered the more "definitive" adaptation of Hiromu Arakawa's manga. It sticks much closer to the source material.
Think of it as the director's cut of your favorite movie. All the plot points are there, delivered with breakneck speed and incredible animation.
It's an epic adventure with a huge cast of characters, intricate political intrigue, and enough action to keep you on the edge of your seat. Trust me, you will love it!
Brotherhood gets straight to the point. It condenses the early story, assuming you already know the basics. It's like jumping right into the second book of a series. You might be a bit lost at first, but you'll catch up fast!
The Downsides of Diving Straight into Brotherhood
The biggest drawback? Brotherhood's faster pacing can make the beginning feel a bit rushed. You might miss some of the emotional nuances that the original series explored more fully.
It's like trying to appreciate a fine wine by chugging it. You get the alcohol, but you miss the subtle flavors and aromas!
So, What's the Verdict?
Honestly? There's no "wrong" answer. Both series are fantastic and worth watching. I would recommend starting with the original Fullmetal Alchemist (2003) because it builds the world and the characters slowly.
Then watch Brotherhood for the complete manga experience and the epic scope of the story. This approach gives you a richer appreciation for both versions!
But if you're impatient and want the manga-accurate story ASAP, then dive right into Brotherhood. Just be prepared for a slightly faster pace at the beginning.
The most important thing is to enjoy the ride! So grab some snacks, settle in, and prepare to be amazed by the world of alchemy!
No matter which you choose first, you're in for an incredible journey with Edward and Alphonse. Happy watching!
