Okay, so you're thinking about diving into the amazing world of Fullmetal Alchemist, huh? Awesome choice! But then the big question hits you: should you watch the original series, the 2003 Fullmetal Alchemist, before jumping into Brotherhood?
It's like asking if you should eat the appetizer before the main course. Both are food, both are tasty (hopefully!), but they offer slightly different experiences. Let's break it down!
The Case for Watching the Original First
Think of the 2003 version as your Fullmetal Alchemist "beginner's guide." It's like training wheels on a bicycle before you hit the BMX track. It takes its time introducing you to Amestris, alchemy, and those ever-so-important characters like Edward and Alphonse Elric.
The 2003 series really fleshes out the early story arcs in a way that Brotherhood sometimes speeds through. You get a deeper connection to the supporting characters. It’s like getting to know the barista at your favorite coffee shop – you appreciate your latte a little bit more!
Imagine skipping the origin story of your favorite superhero. Would you really understand why Batman is so brooding if you hadn't seen his parents' pearl necklace snap? The 2003 series gives you that emotional backstory.
Potential Downsides of Starting with the Original
The 2003 series diverges from the manga's storyline significantly. It's like a "What If...?" scenario. Some people love the alternate ending, others not so much.
Also, the animation is… well, it's from 2003. Don't expect the crisp, shiny visuals you get in Brotherhood. It's like comparing a flip phone to a smartphone. Both make calls, but one has better selfies!
The Case for Diving Straight into Brotherhood
Brotherhood is the manga-accurate adaptation. Think of it as the director's cut, the "true" version of the story. It's like reading the book after seeing the movie – you get the full, unfiltered experience.
It's faster-paced and hits all the major plot points like a freight train. If you're impatient and just want to experience the core story, Brotherhood is your express ticket.
The animation in Brotherhood is fantastic. It's like watching a fireworks display – vibrant, exciting, and visually stunning! It truly brings Hiromu Arakawa's vision to life.
Potential Downsides of Skipping the Original
Because it's faster-paced, Brotherhood can feel a little rushed at times. It expects you to pick up on certain things quickly. It’s like trying to learn a new language by just jumping into a conversation with native speakers.
You might miss some of the character development and emotional nuances present in the 2003 series. These nuances are crucial for a better grasp of the characters. Without it, it’s like only knowing the punchline of a joke, but not the setup.
So, What Should You Do?
Honestly, there's no "right" or "wrong" answer. It really boils down to personal preference. It’s like choosing between chocolate and vanilla ice cream; both are delicious!
If you're a completionist and love detailed world-building, start with the 2003 series. If you want the pure manga experience and gorgeous animation, jump straight into Brotherhood.
Or, here's a crazy idea: watch them both! Start with 2003, then watch Brotherhood. See how the stories differ and decide which one you like better. You can never have too much Fullmetal Alchemist!
No matter which path you choose, you're in for an incredible ride. Prepare for amazing characters, complex themes, and enough alchemy to make your head spin! Have fun!
